Musings

New York Rangers: 20 Thoughts on February’s Play

Breaking down all things New York Rangers in February

Happy March! New month means a new 20 Rangers Thoughts column from yours truly covering all things from the previous month. The last month flew by and saw the Rangers go 5-6-1, keeping them towards the bottom of the East division. Once again I am not one for a long introduction, so let’s get into some analysis.

1. Let’s get Mika Zibanejad out of the way. Seemingly after every game he got a decent shot on net, everyone declared him “back.” The reality is him being “back” will be when he regresses back to a normal shooting percentage. However, since the 24th against the Flyers, I’ve liked his game. I think he’s getting close.

Still, there’s little to no time to be patient with him. If the Rangers want to make the playoffs, they need to win, and they need to win now. They cannot afford to have Zibanejad put up as many pointless games as he has been.

2. Regardless of how the rest of the year plays out for Zibanejad, I do not believe he is the long term answer at 1C. I said that before the season as well. Let me be clear, Zibanejad is a 1C talent. However, he will demand a long term contract and his injury and concussion history is far too troubling to give him what he will demand. I expect to see him in a different uniform when his contract expires, unless he is willing to extend for four years or fewer.

3. The Rangers really did miss Filip Chytil. March will be a big month for him to show just how valuable he truly is.

4. I give Ryan Strome a lot of flack, but the guy is doing his job. Stats are good, underlying numbers are good, would like to see fewer penalties, but he’s a fine 2C on a fine contract. He’s not a long-term piece, but for now he’s fine.

5. Last month I covered the atrocity that was the Ryan McDonagh trade. This month I want to talk about the Rick Nash trade. What a wonderful trade that was. The Rangers got a legit top four defenseman in Ryan Lindgren, Ryan Spooner who turned into Ryan Strome, and a first round pick that was leveraged to get K’Andre Miller. What a trade.

6. Back to negativity! Brett Howden might be a 4C on a decent team, but he’s no more than that. Libor Hajek is not an NHL talent. Oof.

7. I am not on the “David Quinn should be fired” train for a variety of reasons. One, I don’t think the Rangers need to make the playoffs this season. If they do, great. If not, it’s fine. They would get trounced in the first round anyway.

Two, the youngsters are developing. Maybe not the way we’d like to see on the scoresheets, but they are developing.

Three, I do not trust the team will make a better hire next go around. Bruce Boudreau would be a nice fit, as would Gerard Gallant, but those are guys you get when you want to take the team to the promised land. The Rangers aren’t quite there yet.

Let David Quinn finish the development phase for this roster, then reconvene when the team is taking the next step. That’s my plan.

8. All of that being said, David Quinn brutally botched the loss against the Flyers on the 24th. The team clearly needed to shorten the bench and he refused to. The team clearly needed PP1 to play more and he refused that. Quinn might be doing a decent job developing players, but his in-game management needs a lot of work.

9. Speaking of PP1, I’m fine with Colin Blackwell playing on it, but I do think Alexis Lafreniere is a better fit. Additionally, I do not understand what the Rangers are doing with PP2. Anthony Bitteto should never go anywhere near a power play unit. Brendan Smith as well. I understand there were injuries, but goodness gracious, give Julien Gauthier a shot. Or Phil Diguiseppe. Or….anyone who has a semblance of offense in their game. Good grief. And if the PP2 is going to be that bad, play them for 15-20 seconds, not a whole minute.

10. I have no idea how much the team did or didn’t like Tony DeAngelo, but this team looks like a tight-knit group right now. I love seeing that. The players seem to genuinely want to play with and for each other. That’s important as a team on the rise.

11. Random, but is anyone missing Lias Andersson these days? Andersson has one point for the Los Angeles Kings in a fourth line role. He’s simply not an NHL-level talent. I’ve said it for a long time, and I stand by it.

12. I’d love to see Morgan Barron get a run with the big club but the team can’t fit it into the salary cap. If my understanding is correct, Tarmo Renaunen can join the team. I’d like to see him get a few games in the NHL.

13. I have nothing to say about the Artemi Panarin situation other than I hope his family is safe.

14. Igor Shesterkin looked fantastic in February. I was disappointed to see Alexandar Georgiev get the start in the last game of the month, but I do get it. Georgiev needs to play some games, and I appreciate the team trying to not overwork Shesterkin like they did Henrik Lundqvist in the past. I’d give it a 60/40 split this season, then 65/35 moving forward for Igor’s long Rangers career.

15. I do not believe fans should be allowed in the building until everyone is fully vaccinated, but the sounds of fans cheering on the Rangers did bring a smile to my face.

16. Last season the Rangers were 13-12 in one goal games. This season, the Rangers are 2-8. That’s the difference between us talking about the Rangers as a top team and a bottom team in the division. Brutal.

17. Day games are miserable affairs.

18. March will be a huge month for the Rangers. 16 games, 11 of them on the road. For this team to have any shot at the playoffs, they’re going to need to become road warriors. I’m very intrigued to see what’s coming. Alexis Lafreniere is playing his best hockey. Kaapo Kakko and Filip Chytil are returning, with Jacob Trouba coming back soon after. This team has the talent to make a run, especially when the one-goal game statistic regresses a bit. By this time next month we should know where the team stands.

19. Jeff Gorton did a phenomenal job filling out the edges of the roster this season, Jack Johnson not included. Colin Blackwell and Kevin Rooney are guys who are contributing and very easily could have been useless enforcers or poor possession players instead. I’m very torn on my overall assessment of Gorton. He’s a good drafter, but he also got gifted Kakko and Lafreniere. He’s been decent at free agency, but also got gifted Panarin. He’s made some decent moves, but also some poor ones.Where I land is he is a decent GM who won’t surprise you with an absolutely horrendous deal, and won’t stun you with this incredible coup. All in all, that makes him someone we don’t have to worry about.

20. I leave you with a piece of trivia. There are 18 skaters (note, NOT goalies) in the NHL today who were originally drafted by the Rangers. Name them all.

Three Stars of the Month:

  1. Adam Fox
  2. Igor Shesterkin
  3. Chris Kreider

Show More
  • This team requires improvement on many levels.
    – The 5v5 play needs to be better.

    – Our PP1 is so much better that PP2 that PP2 should just be the 3rd line and a defensive pair

    – The top line needs to score a goal a game. It isn’t close.

    – DQ still has problems making in-game moves, but he has been limiting Zibanejad’s time, which is now necessary

    – We have 1 good pair on defense and one “okay” pair. The Bitteto and Hajak is just a marginal pair and should get more than 10 minutes a game.

    – It is time that Howden sit or become part of a package as he is not adding anything while on the ice.

  • Generally agree. I would add Strome having clicked with Kreider(in Panarin’s absence) should help improve his trade value. On Lafreniere I noticed he seemed to play better with fans in the stands. 2 game sample size out of 19 games total so i get that point. But he had his best game of the season on Friday vs Boston and now points in back to back games and 3 of the last 4 matches.( I realize no fans at the Washington game) Maybe a coincidence? Turning Lias into Will Cuylle may turn out a lot better than originally thought. Bad pick I get it. Making lemonade out of lemons, not so bad.

    • my guesses

      Ryan Graves
      Lias Andersson
      Filip Chytil
      Kappo Kakko
      Alexis Lafreniere
      K’Andre Miller
      Jesper Fast
      Marc Staal
      Igor Shesterkyn
      Carl Hagelin
      Chris Kreider
      Derek Stepan
      Brady Sjkei
      Michael Del Zotto
      AnthonyDuclair
      JT Miller
      Artem Anisimov
      Pavel Buchnevich

        • He does not but you are only missing one! My hint is that he’s a very forgettable player currently playing about 8 minutes a night for a very bad team lol

          • I’m stumped. Restricting my search to players who average less than twelve minutes, the only name I recognized is Steven Fogarty, but he only played one game and is in the AHL. Of course, there maybe someone like a Tom Pyatt (not him specifically), who was a low draft pick and traded away before he attracted notice.

  • “16. Last season the Rangers were 13-12 in one goal games. This season, the Rangers are 2-8. That’s the difference between us talking about the Rangers as a top team and a bottom team in the division. Brutal.”

    That has everything to do with Mika’s game … and his game more than likely has to do with not fully recovering from Covid. He may be “healthy” right now, but Covid set him back in terms of prepping for training camp and training camp itself. Plus we can talk about fully recovering from Covid, but what does that really mean? Sure, he’s fine for everyday life … but the difference between an effective player and a less effective player is measured in very small increments. He’s just “off”, he’s thinking the game slower, his skating is just a tad slower, his conditioning may be affected, etc. It doesn’t take much to go from an excellent player/superstar to a mediocrity, or worse.

  • Excellent article, Brandon.

    #5. I think most people forget that it is not at all unusual, when you trade an established player for prospects, that you end up with a lopsided trade. You just can’t fully anticipate what the kids will become. Hence the Nash and McDonagh trades are just not that out of the ordinary. One has to assess the GM by considering them all as a group rather than individually.

    #1. I’d like to see DQ give Zib a few games off. This could be a big plus if he is still having physical effects for cover and it may be a psychological help. Telling him we really need him is obviously not helping and the Panarin situation just added pressure.

    Finally, and this goes somewhat against my last point, I’d like to see DQ try to establish some regular flow. For starters, play Shesterkin five games in a row. He is a playmaker, but this is worthless without any team rhythm. It seems to me that one thing Shesty can do (which Hank never could) is to occasionally keep the opposition from changing the penalty killers on a power play. But the Rangers seem to play as if they have a generic goalie.

    • Buffalo ran with Ullmark for a bunch of games in a row, now they don’t even have him because he tweaked his knee.

      It was dumb luck(and truculent play from Boston) that got Georgiev hurt, but whipping your horse hard is something you save for the playoffs. It’s not like Georgiev was sharp even before he got nicked up.

      • I don’t want to use Shesterkin exclusively. I am not suggesting five games on, one off, 5 on, one off. What I am advocating is a single five game run – a stretch where Rangers play like he’s their goalie. Then they return to some set up where Shesty plays maybe 2/3 of the games. It also isn’t ideal if the first time he ever has an intense schedule is in the playoffs.

        • Your understanding of physiology is lacking.

          Still too early to determine a workhorse(though it really is Shestyorkin) and the ideal is to be peaking for the playoffs to handle the workload. If you run anybody out to be the man in a span of 5 games in 8 nights(which is how the schedule is shaping up) you risk overworking them into either injury or into subpar performance.

          You alternate starts until a goalie can get 2 nights off, then you start your #1 and restart the clock. The Rangers had been doing that until Sunday.

  • Great trivia question… here’s my list in the order I thought of/guessed, with 2 in question.
    1. Kaapo Kakko
    2. Alexis Lafreniere
    3. K Miller
    4. JT Miller
    5. Fast
    6. Hagelin
    7. Staal
    8. Graves
    9. Buchnevich
    10. Kreider
    11. Chytil
    12. Andersson
    13. McIllrath?
    14. Anisimov
    15. Stepan
    16. Skjei
    17. Dubinsky?
    18. Del Zotto

  • Laf
    Kakko
    Miller
    Chytil
    Lias (unsure if he counts)
    Shesty
    Buch
    Duclair
    Graves
    Skjei
    Miller
    Fast
    Kreider
    MDZ
    Stepan
    Weise
    Anisimov
    Staal

    That’s 18, if Lias counts.

  • When you write that Gorton is a good drafter; yet only 18 skaters drafted by the Rangers in the NHL, means the Rangers don’t draft or develop well.

    In comparison, when the Devils were winning cups, they had 50 players drafted or signed and developed by them playing in the NHL. Those guys are all over pro hockey nowadays in management positions.

    • Little unfair to Gorton, he’s only been running the show for a few years now. That isn’t enough time to give him for his guys to develop into NHL players. Hit hit vs. miss ratio is good. Sather’s was….not.

  • Back to top button
    >