As I’ve spent time learning more about the 1994 New York Rangers and their Stanley Cup run, one theme keeps coming up: grit over skill. Head coach Mike Keenan wasn’t shy about reshaping the roster to fit his vision of a tougher, more playoff-ready team. Mike Gartner was one high-profile example. Another, and in many ways an even more complicated one, was the trade of Tony Amonte.
If you are willing and able to support neuroblastoma research, a rare type of childhood cancer, please do so by clicking here to donate. BSB will be presenting the MVP Awards for both Play Like A Pro Charity Games at MSG this coming Monday. A $500 donation has been made to Band of Parents.
Tony Amonte was drafted 68th overall by the Rangers in the 1988 NHL Entry Draft. A dynamic winger with high-end offensive ability, he made his NHL debut during the 1991 playoffs and quickly established himself as one of the organization’s most promising young players. Over his first two full seasons (1991–92 and 1992–93), he totaled 145 points in 162 games, scoring over 30 goals as a rookie and finishing third in Calder Trophy voting.
Through parts of three seasons in New York, Tony Amonte scored 84 goals in 234 games. But during the 1993–94 campaign, his production dipped to 16 goals and 22 assists in 72 games. Like Gartner, Tony Amonte appeared to fall out of favor with Keenan. Whether it was style of play, trust, or something less tangible, Keenan was not fully convinced he could win with him.
On March 21, 1994, with just seven games remaining in the regular season, the Rangers made a franchise-altering move. Tony Amonte and Matt Oates were traded to the Chicago Blackhawks in exchange for Stephane Matteau and Brian Noonan. It was part of a series of aggressive deadline deals that also brought in Craig MacTavish and Glenn Anderson. All four newcomers had ties to Keenan and fit the mold he wanted: Bigger, grittier, battle-tested players he believed were built for the playoffs.
In the short term, the strategy worked. Anderson contributed three playoff goals. Matteau etched his name into Rangers history with two overtime game-winners in the Eastern Conference Finals. Noonan added physicality and depth. MacTavish won what is still considered the most famous faceoff in franchise history in Game 7 of the Stanley Cup Final. The Rangers ended their 54-year championship drought.
But what did they give up?
Tony Amonte, only 24 at the time of the trade, blossomed into a star in Chicago. Reunited with former junior teammate Jeremy Roenick, he became one of the league’s most consistent scorers. Over 627 games with the Blackhawks, he recorded 268 goals and 273 assists, posting three 40-goal seasons and six 30-goal campaigns. He strung together a five-season stretch without missing a single game and reached a career-high 84 points in 1999–2000.
He later played for the Phoenix Coyotes, Philadelphia Flyers, and Calgary Flames, scoring his 400th NHL goal in 2005 against the Ottawa Senators. Internationally, he represented the United States and scored the dramatic game-winning goal against Canada in the 1996 World Cup of Hockey final. When he retired in 2008, he had compiled 900 points in 1,174 NHL games.
The numbers underscore the long-term cost. Between Tony Amonte, Mike Gartner, and Todd Marchant, another young player moved in that stretch. The Rangers gave up 1,435 games, 457 goals, and 970 points of future production, along with 112 playoff games and 58 postseason points for their new teams. In contrast, the four players acquired at the deadline combined for 166 regular-season games as Rangers, producing 37 goals and 64 points, before adding 105 playoff games and 32 postseason points.
And yet, none of that matters if you’re judging solely by banners. The Rangers don’t win the Stanley Cup in 1994 without those moves. The franchise’s drought ends. History is made.
Still, more than any other deal from that deadline, the Amonte trade stands as a reminder of the price of going all-in. It wasn’t quite a Rick Middleton-level regret, but watching Amonte develop into a prolific, long-term star elsewhere served as a lingering reminder of what the Rangers sacrificed for that championship.
The lesson is simple: mortgaging the future only works if you win the Cup. In 1994, the Rangers did. But the “what if” surrounding Tony Amonte will always be part of that story.
More About:Players