Mid-season report card: the goalies

Jared Silber/NHLI via Getty Images

The Rangers went into this season with question marks surrounding both of their goaltenders.  Henrik Lundqvist was shaking off questions about an uncharacteristically poor season last year, and Ondrej Pavelec, Benoit Allaire’s latest pet project, had one foot out of the NHL.  There were good reasons for fans and pundits alike to be skeptical of the stability in the Ranger crease, especially with Lundqvist turning 36 this season and the ridiculously high-quality backup goaltenders the Rangers have had the past four years.

At the halfway mark of the season, it seems that many of those fears have been unfounded (mine included), as both goaltenders have been strong through the team’s first 42 games. Let’s a dig a little deeper at each of their respective performances, shall we?

Henrik Lundqvist


There is no question that Hank did not have a great year last season.  However, after the Rangers were eliminated from the playoffs, Lundqvist headed over to the World Championships and helped Sweden capture a gold medal.  Watching him play in those games, you could tell that his skills weren’t seriously deteriorating and made me optimistic for a bounce back this season.  My, what a rebound it has been.

Let’s start with the rate stats (much to my dismay).  Hank is sporting a slightly above league average 2.52 GAA and a well above-average .924 save percentage.  Obviously, the save percentage is the number his supporters are focusing on, as it is .004 above his career .920 save percentage and miles ahead of his .910 save percentage from last season.  His raw save percentage is good for 5th in the NHL amongst goaltenders playing at least 20 games.

So, why is there such a disconnect between his save percentage and GAA rankings?  It really starts with the performance in front of him.  First, let’s take a look at his expected stats.  Through 42 games, Lundqvist has allowed 63 goals.  His xGA (expected goals against) is 73.  This logically dove tails into his 10 GSAA (goals saved above average), which is good for third in the NHL, behind only Sergei Bobrovsky and Andre Vasilevskiy’s ridiculous 15+ counts.

This is relatively easily explained by looking at the batsh*t crazy levels of HD shots against that Hank has faced thus far.  See below in both numerical and heat map form:


Will you take a look at that freaking heat map? Hank should honest-to-god mutiny.  I have my pet theory on why a relatively talented defense corps hemorrhages shots to this extent (*coughsystemcough*), but that’s not really the point of this analysis.  The point is that Lundqvist, at age 35, mind you, is facing a cruel and unusual level of HD shots against, while putting up rate stats and advanced analytics at or near the top of the league.

Minor tweaks in his style have been at the forefront of his resurgence.  Retreating (no pun intended) from the goal line blocking style that has been his trademark since his emergence in the NHL, Hank has become a bit more dynamic in his save selections and crease depth.  He has tailored his movements and picked his spots to be aggressive in situations where players do not have multiple options and he can zero in on the puck carrier.  This has improved his MD save% greatly, which has buoyed his overall stats.

My longwinded grade: A, Dave’s much more concise grade: ????

Ondrej Pavelec

New York Daily News

I will openly admit I was very skeptical of the Rangers’ acquisition of Ondrej Pavelec in the offseason.  He was no spring chicken anymore and had a history of suspect work ethic and an overreliance on his (admittedly, considerable) natural talent.  The concept here was that Benoit Allaire would work his voodoo magic with Pavelec and he could be a force in a 25-30 game sample.  It took a little bit of adjustment, but it appears we are finally starting to see the fruits of that labor.

Starting again at the rate stats, Pavelec sports an (eerily similar to Hank) 2.55 GAA and a .926 save percentage.  Obviously, the save percentage is outstanding for a backup, and the GAA confirms the deficiencies cited above for Lundqvist.  However, they have done it in completely different ways.

Pavelec has made up for a lack of success on HD shots with an astounding consistency on LD and MD shots.  The difference in net front systems comes into play here. Hank tends to prefer a net fronting strategy (see a refresher on d-zone strategies from our resident x’s and o’s guy, The Suit, right here), whereas AV tends to prefer a side net strategy with the backups.  As you can see from the heat map below, the Rangers have done a better job protecting the front of the net from HD shots in Pavelec’s games than in Hank’s.  Now, a couple of caveats here, the right-side HD shot disproportionality is likely sample size noise (369 min), rather than our left defensemen being that much better than the right defensemen.


Either way, Pavelec hasn’t had much success with the HD shots so far, so it makes sense that the team would endeavor to shield him from those types of chances.  This could be sample size noise as well, but let’s face it, most backup goaltenders’ seasons are predicated on noise because of their inherently smaller samples.

Up to this point, Pavelec has been everything that the Rangers could have hoped he could be: B+

All stats via Corsica.Hockey

"Mid-season report card: the goalies", 5 out of 5 based on 5 ratings.

9 thoughts on “Mid-season report card: the goalies

  • Jan 12, 2018 at 7:16 am

    Agree on Hank’s grade, but I’d actually give Pavelec an A as well. He has had some huge games especially against Pitt and Caps. Not easy to do when you get so few starts.

    • Jan 12, 2018 at 8:04 am

      Agree, Pav seems like an A given the expectations he’s exceeded. Tough job backing up with not many opportunities.

      The goalies are the reason I think this team can’t contend. They’ve covered up so many weaknesses in their own end. I hope Gorton sees through that, realizes that AV’s system is not working, fires him and does not buy at the deadline. And better yet, makes the hard decision to sell a couple assets (Grabs & Nash) that I really like in return for a mini haul in young assets.

      • Jan 12, 2018 at 8:23 am

        The only thing that kept Pavs from an A was his poor performance against HD shots. If his LD and MD shots regress at all (which they likely will), his numbers will go south in a hurry the way this team hemorrhages quality chances against.

        His performance warrants an A, but his underlying metrics show some cracks in the armor.

    • Jan 12, 2018 at 2:24 pm

      Right on Sittoo … i’d give hank a A+ if he was a little better at the start .. They should be playing Pav a little more as well,think he’s proven he can battle!

      • Jan 12, 2018 at 9:46 pm

        We agreed on something!! Is the world ending? ?

  • Jan 12, 2018 at 8:32 am

    You included my middle finger emoji. You win, sir.

  • Jan 12, 2018 at 9:37 am

    Pavelec deserves an A+, Hank as well. Pavelec is playing at an extremely high level for anyone—let alone a goalie who traditionally posts SV% below league average—and he hasn’t played much, which theoretically should make his backup job more challenging. Pavelec has handled the adjustment to backup amazingly well, particularly for a guy with consistency issues who recently started in the NHL.

    At a time in the season when the Rangers are disintegrating defensively in front of their goalies, the play of Hank & Pav has been unbelievably valuable to their team. Both guys have been outstanding this year, giving their team truly inspired performance from the goaltender position.

  • Jan 12, 2018 at 10:07 am

    I think Allaire gets and A+…those minor tweeks to Hank’s style and Pavelec seemed like he was going to be a problem early on, but he’s really picked it up the past few starts. If you look at Cam Talbot and Antti Raanta, their numbers have dipped since leaving. To be fair to both their teams are not very good. But they have not been great either.

  • Jan 12, 2018 at 8:24 pm


    where can i buy luxury garcinia cambogia

    can i take cough medicine and ibuprofen

    el plan b online subtitulada

    lansoprazole capsules to buy

    wellbutrin xl and birth control pills

    But I’m not sure…

    can i take lamisil while pregnant

    pink viagra price in india

    7gold juve inter $1 000 a pill sovaldi

    a viagra pill

    cialis tadalafil cheapest online

    how to take prednisone taper

    cialis price uk

    generic viagra online in canada

    how fast should diflucan work

    lactulose pill

    how fast should diflucan work

    how to take prednisone 20mg

    carafate liquid price

    is it safe to buy antabuse online

    phenergan generic cost

    can you take gemfibrozil and simvastatin together

    liv 52 pills

    counter pill that works like viagra

    cialis 1 month free trial

    how much does a prescription of viagra cost

    proximity $1 000 a pill sovaldi

    viagra cialis levitra for sale

    can you buy viagra over counter boots

    where to buy cialis with prescription

    viagra for sale

    real viagra for sale canada

    levlen pill

    how many viagra can i take in 24 hours

    best time to take cialis

    dragon bird $1 000 a pill sovaldi

    how much cialis can i take daily

    can you take ibuprofen after surgery

    price cialis 20 mg

    reputable online pharmacy generic viagra

    gol special 2000 $1 000 a pill sovaldi

    how much does a bottle of viagra cost

    taking metronidazole for bv

    cialis super active buy

    can i take lamisil while pregnant

    can i take synthroid with my other medications

    can you buy xenical over the counter in australia

    how do i purchase viagra

    cialis 10mg best price

    zofran dissolvable vs pill

    can i take synthroid with my other medications

    buy cialis no rx

    boots pharmacy viagra cost

    levitra 20mg pills

    best time to take cialis 5mg for bph

    best cialis online canadian pharmacy

    can i buy viagra at a gas station

    can you take xanax with ibuprofen 800

    green coffee bean pills and garcinia cambogia

    buy cheap flagyl

    how can i get viagra without a prescription

    can you take famotidine with tums

    buy viagra in vegas

    what are indomethacin pills used for

Comments are closed.