New York Rangers defense: Just survive

Photo: AP
Photo: AP

Good news folks, Derek Stepan is almost ready to return for injury. Figured I may as well lead with that.

The six defensemen that started for the Rangers on opening night: Dan Girardi, Marc Staal, Dan Boyle, Ryan McDonagh, Kevin Klein, John Moore. Only the first two will dress tonight, and may be the only two that dress for the next four games. No matter what side of the fence you fall on regarding Girardi/Anton Stralman, or Staal, or Klein, or Moore, you recognize that this is a significant problem.

Boyle went down first with a broken hand two periods into the season. Then Moore was suspended for five games. Then over the weekend the club lost McDonagh for 4-6 weeks with a separated shoulder and Klein for at least one game with a foot contusion. Saying that this situation isn’t ideal is a drastic understatement.

The Rangers are looking at reuniting Staal and Girardi as the top pairing. In reality, they are best served as a second pairing, since the #fancystats don’t favor either player, and Girardi’s lack of foot speed is being exploited fairly often. But no matter which way you look at it, Girardi’s part cyborg, so he gets the benefit of the doubt from me. Staal and Girardi can fake it as a top pairing. They are the least of my concerns.

Matt Hunwick and Mike Kostka are now the second pairing on defense. Hunwick has been a decent surprise this year, and has held his own. But, his career numbers aren’t promising –he’s been a 7D his entire career, an up and down guy– and the #fancystats aren’t fun to look at. Kostka is in the same boat. This is usually your fourth pairing, not your second.

Conor Allen and Dylan McIlrath, just recalled yesterday, will likely be your third pairing tonight. There’s not enough information at the NHL level to make a valid conclusion, but now is their biggest test. If Allen can at least mimic Moore and McIlrath mimic Klein, I’ll call that a draw. All things considered, I wouldn’t be surprised if they surpassed those expectations.

With Allen, his biggest strength is his ability to move the puck. If he can do half of what Stralman did (continually make smart, short passes in the zone that move the puck up), then I’ll be happy. As for McIlrath, I’m intrigued to see how he does against NHL competition. His skating is not his strength, but solid positioning and smart plays with the puck can tilt the ice in his favor.

We may be in for a rough few games. Henrik Lundqvist is going to need to bail the team out this week. Maybe we can luck out, and Allen/McIlrath can fake it as a second pairing for a short period of time. I highly doubt they can be worse than Hunwick/Kostka. But for the next few games, the blue line will look like a preseason lineup.

Show More
  • The Rangers will be winning ugly for the next week or so. I doubt we are going to see 4 Rangers flying up the ice as a group like we have for most of the time AV has been the coach.

    The good news is we get to see what we have in the kids. I think Allen is going to be a pleasant surprise for everyone.

  • To Sather’s credit, he has really improved our depth this year – more up front than on D but an improvement nonetheless.

    Here’s what we were treated to in 2012-13 (a 48 game season, btw):
    Steve Eminger: 35 games
    Roman Hamrlik: 12 games
    Stu Bickel: 16 games
    Matt Gilroy: 15 games

    Once we got John Moore in the Gaborik trade, these four were our 7D-10D. Only Gilroy has played a single NHL game since then – 16 for Florida in 2013-4.

    I don’t know about you but Hunwick, Kostka, Allen and McIlrath as our 7D-10D look better in that context. This isn’t good and I may be grasping at a straw or two here but I need something to get me through the next two weeks!

    • Hey, in a capped league no team can roll 10 deep on the blue line unless they have 3 top level prospects stuck in the minors.

      Like you said, Hunwick, Kostka, Allen and McIlrath is so much better than Eminger, Hamrlik, Bickel and Gilroy. Eminger might be the best of that group but Gilroy and Bickel are by far the worst out of those eight names.

      Boston went through the same thing two years ago IIRC, and from that experience they discovered Torey Krug and Kevan Miller. Let’s hope McIlrath and Allen really blow us away with this opportunity.

  • Back to top button